Experiments on Causal Exclusion.


Blanchard, T., Murray, D., & Lombrozo, T. (Forthcoming). Experiments on Causal Exclusion. Mind and Language.
PDF1.24 MB


Intuitions play an important role in debates on the causal status of high-level properties. For instance, Kim has claimed that his “exclusion argument” relies on “a perfectly intuitive. . . understanding of the causal relation.” We report the results of three experiments examining whether laypeople really have the relevant intuitions. We find little support for Kim’s view and the principles on which it relies. Instead, laypeople are willing to count both a multiply-realized property and its realizers as causes, and find the systematic overdetermination implied by this view unproblematic..

See also: Journal Article
Last updated on 07/13/2020